15 Top Islands in the Continental U.S. — Featuring Stunning Views, Tranquil Nature, and Relaxed Atmosphere

Capturing the diverse and expansive nature of American experiences, this year’s list of the best islands in the continental U.S. does just that. Discover charming, classic Americana in Martha’s Vineyard and Nantucket, Massachusetts, explore the rugged pine forests and breathtaking vistas of Mount Desert Island in Maine, or enjoy the easygoing, sandy beach atmosphere of the Florida Keys. Visit Washington’s San Juan Islands for sea kayaking and orca sightings, or dress up for an elegant evening of fine dining and chamber music on Amelia Island, Florida. These islands showcase the incredible natural and cultural variety that our own backyard has to offer.

Understanding How Voting Works

For our annual World's Best Awards survey, T+L invites readers to share their travel experiences worldwide—evaluating the best hotels, resorts, cities, islands, cruise ships, spas, airlines, and more. This year, over 186,000 T+L readers participated in the 2024 survey, casting more than 700,000 votes across 8,700 properties (including hotels, cities, cruise lines, etc.).

Islands were rated based on the following criteria:

Natural attractions and beaches
Activities and sights
Dining and food
Hospitality and friendliness
Overall value

Participants in the survey rated each characteristic as excellent, above average, average, below average, or poor. The final scores reflect the average of these ratings.

What Readers Adored

Every destination on this year's list inspired enthusiastic feedback from T+L readers eager to highlight what made each location remarkable. A common thread among the 15 featured islands and archipelagos is their cherished status among travelers. For instance, one reader described the San Juan Islands (No. 7) as “truly breathtaking,” while another praised its “stunning nature,” noting the atmosphere as “relaxing and peaceful.” One fan expressed a particular fondness for Orcas Island, stating, “It’s my favorite, and I visit eight to ten times a year. The natural beauty is incredible, there’s plenty to do, the locals are friendly, and every restaurant has great food.” In contrast, Amelia Island (No. 2) attracts visitors not only for its scenic landscapes but also its vibrant community. “Amelia Island is a must-visit for anyone who values history, a small-town vibe, and unique experiences,” wrote a reader. “[It’s] the only place in America that has been influenced by four distinct cultures: Native American, French, Spanish, and British, all of which are reflected in the town’s architecture and layout.” Meanwhile, Mackinac Island (No. 3) drew rave reviews from fans enamored with its charming old-fashioned feel. “We love that there are no cars—just horses and bicycles,” remarked a reader. No matter what type of island lifestyle you seek, you’ll find it among the selections ahead.

The Champion

Golden Isles, Georgia (Jekyll Island, Little St. Simons Island, Sea Island, St. Simons Island)

Caucasian mother pulling her son in a cart along the beach at the Golden Isles

Marc Romanelli/Getty Images

While often viewed as a single destination, seasoned visitors and locals understand that these four islands along the Georgia coast each possess their unique culture and charm. Sea Island exudes Southern sophistication, Little St. Simons Island remains a pristine coastal sanctuary with just one luxury lodge, St. Simons boasts a vibrant community and some of the best barbecue in the area, and Jekyll Island blends aspects of all three, showcasing remnants of Gilded Age luxury alongside family-friendly beaches and vast stretches of untouched forests and tidal marshes. It seems every reader has a favorite island. Regarding Jekyll Island, one reader mentioned, “There's no better place for complete peace, relaxation, and fun. It’s the total package; the entire area is perfect.” Another voter expressed their love for Little St. Simons, describing it as “truly a magical place. It’s wonderful to unplug and reconnect with nature.” A couple of readers shared their enjoyment of visiting multiple islands: “I love Jekyll Island for a relaxed day, while St. Simons is my choice for nightlife,” one said, and another simply stated, “Absolutely stunning islands! Some of the most beautiful I’ve ever visited.”