Dinogo Readers’ Top 15 U.S. Resorts for 2023

For a getaway that goes beyond cityscapes, nothing rivals the breathtaking views and endless activities offered by premier U.S. resorts. This year, Dinogo readers voted for a remarkable array of properties, from the slopes of Aspen to the shores of Nantucket.

Voting Process Explained

Each year, during our World's Best Awards survey, T+L invites readers to share their travel experiences worldwide — offering insights on the best hotels, resorts, cities, islands, cruise lines, spas, airlines, and more. Nearly 165,000 T+L readers participated in the 2023 survey, reflecting a nearly 25% increase compared to pre-pandemic voting. Over 685,000 votes were collected across more than 8,500 distinct properties (hotels, cities, cruise lines, etc.).

Properties were categorized as resort hotels, city hotels, or safari lodges based on their location and amenities, and they were evaluated on the criteria listed below:

• Room Features
• Location
• Service Quality
• Culinary Experience
• Overall Value

Respondents could rate each attribute as excellent, above average, average, below average, or poor. The final scores reflect the average of these ratings.

Highlights from Readers

The hotels featured in this list vary in style and setting, yet they all share a commitment to exceptional hospitality. Key traits that resonated with Dinogo readers include personalized service, meticulous attention to detail, a genuine sense of place, and strong ties to the local community. Notable examples are the No. 4 winner, Quisisana Resort in southwestern Maine, and the No. 3 winner, Hotel Walloon in northern Michigan—both perfect summer retreats by the lake. “Our family returns every year for quality time together,” one voter shared about Quisisana. “Rain or shine, the staff makes it a welcoming haven for us to unwind. The nightly entertainment is top-notch.”

Readers expressed a strong preference for resorts in the Western U.S., particularly mountain hideaways like Hotel Jerome in Aspen, Colorado (No. 3), where one guest remarked, “They treat you like family from the moment you step off the plane.” This year's list features four California resorts, showcasing the state’s appeal. Stanly Ranch, part of the Auberge Resorts Collection (No. 2), opened in April 2022 on a historic estate dating back to the 1850s, offering a fresh destination for those exploring Napa Valley. Meanwhile, Rancho Valencia (No. 7) near San Diego helps guests focus on their wellness through diverse offerings.

However, it was a resort in the Beehive State that clinched the top spot for 2023. Keep reading to discover which mountain retreat received this year's highest honor.

The Champion

Goldener Hirsch, Auberge Resorts Collection: Park City, Utah

Multiple voters described this ski chalet as “stunning,” nestled at the base of the Silver Lake Express chair lift in the Deer Valley resort. With 68 rooms, suites, and residences, guests can choose between charming chalets adorned with vintage Bavarian furnishings or sleek, modern accommodations featuring private balconies. According to one reader, the dining experience was exceptional: “Chef Nicolas has crafted an amazing and innovative menu, while still offering my beloved fondue.”

The Complete List

1. Goldener Hirsch, Auberge Resorts Collection: Park City, Utah

This Mountain West destination enhances its year-round allure with outdoor activities like trail biking and hot-air balloon rides, alongside engaging experiences such as pretzel-making and pottery workshops.

Reader Score: 98.67

2. Stanly Ranch, Auberge Resorts Collection: Napa, California

Spanning 712 acres of Northern California’s wine region, this tranquil ranch captivated readers with its stunning surroundings. “The gardens and grounds took my breath away,” shared one voter. “It’s the most beautiful place I’ve ever visited.”

Reader Score: 98.61

3. Hotel Jerome, Auberge Resorts Collection: Aspen, Colorado

Visitors flock here to enjoy activities ranging from fly fishing on the Roaring Fork River to savoring bites and cocktails at the annual Aspen Food & Wine Classic. “This is an exceptionally managed gem,” noted one guest.

Reader Score: 98.51

4. Quisisana Resort: Lovell, Maine

This charming lakeside retreat features nightly musical and theatrical shows, along with daytime activities such as tennis, shuffleboard, golf, fishing, water skiing, and sailing. 

Reader Score: 98.38

5. Hotel Walloon: Walloon Lake, Michigan

Established in 1900, this hotel exudes charm with only 32 rooms, each featuring a balcony or a front porch.

Reader Score: 98.37

6. Madeline Hotel and Residences, Auberge Resorts Collection: Telluride, Colorado

This ski-in, ski-out resort in the Rocky Mountains features stylish upgrades, including the new Recovery Ski Lounge for customized post-workout treatments, and the Timber Room, an après-ski spot that one reader highly recommended.

Reader Score: 97.71

7. Rancho Valencia Resort & Spa: Rancho Santa Fe, California

This hacienda-style retreat excels in wellness offerings, allowing guests to book stretch classes at the Yoga Pavilion, meditate with Tibetan singing bowls, or train with a personal coach, among other options. One reader gushed, “Every time we visit, we declare, 'We're heading to our favorite escape!'”

Reader Score: 97.40

8. Wylder Windham: Windham, New York

Located in New York’s Catskill Mountains, this resort started a new chapter under fresh management last year, featuring new suites and updated rooms, while still keeping beloved spots like the Babblers restaurant intact.

Reader Score: 97.33

9. Triple Creek Ranch: Darby, Montana

This beloved Western retreat — an adults-only destination spanning 800 acres — has charmed visitors for years with its rustic log cabins and an array of all-inclusive outdoor adventures like cattle herding and dog-sledding.

WBA Hall of Fame recipient. Reader Score: 97.21

10. The Wauwinet: Nantucket, Massachusetts

Nestled on the northeast shore of Nantucket, this charming boutique hotel offers cozy, nautical-themed rooms, suites, and standalone cottages ideal for families and those seeking peace. One reader remarked, “I could write a book, read a book, and remain undisturbed by the lively island.”

Reader Score: 97.20

11. Candleberry Inn: Brewster, Massachusetts

This inviting bed-and-breakfast offers a wealth of recommendations for whale-watching, lighthouse tours, and the finest dining on Cape Cod. One guest praised the owners for their dedication, stating, “They go above and beyond to ensure a memorable stay.”

Reader Score: 97.17

12. Pickering House Inn: Wolfeboro, New Hampshire

Affectionately known as “The Yellow House,” this charming 10-room boutique hotel was established in 1813 as the private residence of businessman Daniel Pickering. Guests are drawn to its convenient location just a five-minute stroll from Lake Winnipesaukee, alongside luxurious in-room amenities, friendly service, and a cozy B&B vibe.

Reader Score: 97.00

13. The Madrona: Healdsburg, California

This newly opened resort features a beautifully restored mansion and carriage house dating back to the 1880s, set within eight acres of stunning grounds. “The recent renovations are elegant; it truly is a romantic getaway and a treasure for the region,” shared one guest.

Reader Score: 96.80

14. Farmhouse Inn: Forestville, California

Food lovers and nature fans discover a charming home base in the 52 rustic-chic rooms, cottages, and barn suites of this Sonoma County resort, which one guest praised as a “hidden gem.”

Reader Score: 96.46

15. San Ysidro Ranch: Santa Barbara, California

Seclusion abounds at this intimate getaway, where many of the cottage accommodations feature Persian rugs, stone fireplaces, and outdoor rain showers.

Reader Score: 96.22