8 exciting shows heading to Broadway and beyond this fall

New York City is among the top destinations globally for live theater. Whether you're seeking vibrant new musicals, star-studded plays, classic revivals, or daring productions, you'll find it all under Broadway's dazzling lights and in cozy theaters around the city.

There are numerous Broadway shows from last season that deserve your attention: consider the Tony Award-winning musical The Outsiders, the immersive three-hour rock drama Stereophonic, and Cole Escola's wildly queer hit Oh, Mary! If you aim to stay in the know with NYC's theater elite, now is the perfect time to grab tickets to the upcoming shows yet to premiere.

Here are some of the most talked-about productions launching this autumn, along with tips on how to score tickets and enjoy performances like a true culture aficionado in New York. 

Exciting new Broadway musicals to anticipate this fall

1. Sunset Boulevard 

St James Theater Previews start September 28; opens October 20

Former Pussycat Doll Nicole Scherzinger prepares for her role as Norma Desmond – the faded silent-film star yearning for a comeback – in this minimalist, film-inspired revival from London. This psychological thriller, adapted from the classic 1950 film noir, features a score by Andrew Lloyd Webber and a book and lyrics by Don Black and Christopher Hampton. Expect a fresh take rather than a traditional museum piece: director Jamie Lloyd's bold reimagining was a hit overseas, winning seven Olivier Awards (Britain's highest theater accolades) in 2024, including Best Musical Revival and Best Actress. 

2. Gypsy

Majestic Theater Previews start November 21; opens December 19

It's time for six-time Tony winner Audra McDonald to shine as she takes on the role of musical theater's most notorious stage mom in this highly anticipated revival. The original show, which premiered in 1959 with a book by Arthur Laurents, music by Jule Styne, and lyrics by Stephen Sondheim, was inspired by the memoir of burlesque icon Gypsy Rose Lee, detailing her tumultuous childhood and ascent to stardom under the watchful eye of her domineering mother, Rose. Just as King Lear is for Broadway's leading ladies, Rose has been portrayed by legendary performers such as Ethel Merman, Angela Lansbury, Bernadette Peters, and Patti LuPone. McDonald's rendition is sure to carve out its own legacy among the greats of Gypsy lore. 

3. Death Becomes Her 

Lunt-Fontanne Theater Previews begin October 23; opens November 21

The iconic 1992 film featuring Meryl Streep and Goldie Hawn as fierce rivals in pursuit of eternal youth is being transformed into a theatrical spectacle. Talented singer-comediennes Megan Hilty (from TV's Smash) and Jennifer Simard (a two-time Tony nominee and expert scene-stealer) will play the feuding divas in this zany musical, with a book by Marco Pennette (known for TV comedy Ugly Betty) and a score by fresh talents Julia Mattison and Noel Carey. The cast also includes Christopher Sieber (another two-time Tony nominee) as the object of their rivalry, along with Destiny's Child's Michelle Williams portraying a potion-selling seductress. 

Exciting new Broadway dramas to anticipate this fall

4. The Roommate 

Booth Theater Previews start August 29; opens September 12

Esteemed stars and real-life friends Mia Farrow (known for iconic films like Rosemary's Baby) and Patti LuPone (a three-time Tony Award winner, including her 2022 role as Joanne in Company) team up in this one-act two-hander that explores the quirks of reinvention as AARP-eligible roommates. The script is penned by Jen Silverman, with direction by three-time Tony Award winner Jack O'Brien. 

5. Our Town 

Barrymore Theater Previews start September 17; opens October 10

Thornton Wilder's 1938 Pulitzer Prize-winning depiction of small-town America and the marvels of life returns to Broadway in a new production directed by Kenny Leon. Jim Parsons (The Big Bang Theory) serves as the narrator, the Stage Manager, alongside Katie Holmes (Dawson's Creek) and a cast of Broadway veterans, including Julie Halston (Sex and the City) and Tony nominee Ephraim Sykes. 

6. Eureka Day 

Samuel J. Friedman Theater Previews start November 25; opens December 16

This thought-provoking and timely play explores a heated discussion about mandatory mumps vaccinations during a meeting between educators and parents at a private California elementary school. Premiering in 2018, playwright Jonathan Spector's narrative resonates powerfully in the wake of the pandemic. Directed by Anna D. Shapiro (known for Broadway's August: Osage County), this production arrives just in time for flu-shot season. The impressive cast features Tony winner Bill Irwin alongside seasoned actors Jessica Hecht and Amber Gray. 

Exciting Off-Broadway productions to watch for this fall

Broadway isn't the only venue for exceptional theater. Some of New York's most groundbreaking performances occur in smaller, more remote theaters throughout the city, serving as creative hubs for both new and established talent. Here are some upcoming shows that are definitely worth a visit. 

7. The Big Gay Jamboree

Orpheum Theater Previews start September 14; opens October 1

Marla Mindelle (co-creator of Titanique, the playful Off-Broadway Titanic parody) is the mastermind behind what promises to be a delightfully queer and cheeky tribute to musical theater. Mindelle stars as Stacey, who finds herself trapped in a Golden Age musical she desperately wants to escape. 

8. King Lear 

The Griffin Theater at The Shed Previews start October 26; opens November 14

British actor and filmmaker Kenneth Branagh takes the helm at Hudson Yards' Shed as Shakespeare's power-hungry ruler, seeking ultimate loyalty and control – a poignant reflection on today's political climate as voters approach the US presidential election. 

Broadway FAQs

When is the best time to buy tickets? 

If you’re set on seeing a specific show, it’s wise to buy tickets as early as possible, even months in advance—especially for popular musicals and limited runs featuring top-tier performers. Discounts are rare for the hottest tickets in town, so it’s worth investing a bit more to secure your spot for the season’s best performances. (Check reviews in the New York Times and Vulture for guidance on what to see.) 

How can I buy tickets and find discounts? 

For the best seats or highly sought-after shows, consider purchasing tickets directly from the show's website. Even better, visiting the theater's box office in person can help you avoid often-high digital transaction fees.

The TodayTix app is another excellent option for securing tickets, offering discounts and digital lotteries. Some shows allow you to select specific seats via the app, while others may only let you choose a general section. 

If you're in NYC and seeking substantial discounts, visit the Theatre Development Fund's TKTS booth beneath the red steps of Times Square's where you can find same-day tickets and next-day matinees at up to 50% off. Major hits are typically not available here; the listings usually consist of shows that have been running for a while, are underperforming, or are still in previews (before reviews are published). Check the TKTS website for real-time availability, but be aware that tickets may sell out quickly.

For the cheapest tickets around, explore same-day lottery and rush programs; many shows also offer standing-room tickets. Review the Playbill.com's cheat sheet for specific policies for each show. Scoring these limited, day-of-performance tickets can be challenging, so it’s wise to have a backup plan. 

When is the best time to catch a Broadway show? 

Most shows run six days a week. While schedules can differ, most theaters are closed on Mondays and feature both matinee and evening performances on Wednesdays and Saturdays. Tuesday shows often have earlier start times—great if you prefer an early night. Weekend evening audiences can be more boisterous, making it perfect for comedies. You'll generally find the best deals on weekday matinees. 

What items are allowed in the theater? 

You can bring a small bag that fits under your seat (like a purse, backpack, or shopping tote). However, avoid large suitcases or bulky items. Most theaters offer a coat check for safe storage, but be prepared for potential wait times before and after the show. 

Outside food and drinks are not permitted in theaters, although many allow sealed water bottles. Expect a quick bag check at the entrance as part of the security measures. 

What attire is appropriate? 

Theatergoers wear a variety of outfits: from cocktail dresses and suits to jeans, t-shirts, and shorts, all are welcome. Aim for smart-casual to blend in with the locals (wedding attire is too formal, while gym wear feels too casual). Don’t stress about it: once the lights dim, everyone looks similar.