This Incredible Hotel in Dominica Has Just Been Named the Best Caribbean Resort by T+L Readers — Here’s Why

Can you really go wrong in the Caribbean? Just close your eyes, choose an island, and you’re almost guaranteed stunning blue skies and endless turquoise waters, along with sunny days, vibrant tropical greenery, and likely a couple of white-sand beaches within reach. Yet, there’s a way to experience even more in the Caribbean, including Bermuda and the Bahamas.

The 25 resorts featured here provide the perfect setting for an opulent island escape filled with luxury, outstanding service, fresh seafood, and countless unforgettable experiences. Whether you’re seeking thrilling adventures or simply lounging with a Painkiller in hand, the top resorts favored by Dinogo readers have something for everyone.

Voting Process Overview

Annually, for our World's Best Awards survey, T+L invites readers to share their travel experiences from around the world, expressing their views on the finest hotels, resorts, cities, islands, cruise lines, spas, airlines, and more. This year, over 186,000 T+L readers participated in the 2024 survey, casting a total of more than 700,000 votes across over 8,700 properties, including hotels, cities, cruise lines, and others.

Hotels were categorized as resort hotels, city hotels, inns, or safari lodges based on their location and amenities, and were rated according to the following criteria:

• Room quality and amenities
• Location
• Service quality
• Dining options
• Overall value

Respondents rated each attribute as excellent, above average, average, below average, or poor. The final scores reflect the averages of these ratings.

What Readers Appreciated

The resorts that received the highest praise from readers were spread across 13 different countries and territories. Regardless of the island they visited, T+L readers discovered settings that were simply unparalleled, highlighting how perfectly situated this year's retreats are.

One reader praised Malliouhana (No. 19) in Anguilla, saying, "The location and view are simply amazing. We adored the two stunning pools and the beautiful beaches. Our spacious room offered an incredible view." Another guest echoed this sentiment, stating, "It's a warm and welcoming resort with the finest location on the island."

Cap Maison (No. 13) in St. Lucia received glowing remarks for its breathtaking cliffside setting overlooking Smugglers Cove and proximity to Rodney Bay. "I have never experienced such beauty," one visitor exclaimed. "The accommodations rank among the best I’ve ever encountered, and the on-site restaurant is unparalleled with its exquisite food presentation."

In Negril, Jamaica, Tensing Pen (No. 2) won praise from numerous repeat visitors, scattered across the cliffs with views of rocky coves. One reader, a three-time guest, highlighted the stunning cliffside views, while another has been bringing her family for over 40 years. She recalled honeymooning there and her children learning to swim off the platformed cliffs. "The facilities are gorgeous, and the staff is outstanding," she shared. "Our family albums are filled with memories alongside the Tensing Pen staff," concluding with, "So many memories…so little time."

Continue reading to discover this year’s top winner, along with the complete list of the 25 best resorts in the Caribbean, the Bahamas, and Bermuda—each offering a perfect setting for your next unforgettable adventure.

The Champion

Secret Bay: Portsmouth, Dominica

Known as the Nature Island, Dominica presents Secret Bay as a luxurious entry point to its wild and rugged landscapes. With 22 private villas nestled among sprawling rainforests, this nature-focused retreat provides a serene escape. One guest shared, "We cherished the seclusion of our villa; it was a true oasis in every sense." Another praised the staff for treating guests like family, ensuring they felt unique and valued. One visitor recounted how the team sprang into action to assist with an unusual request: a trail-clearing project at a friend's estate nearby. "The concierge organized a crew to support us, providing machetes and refreshing cold water," he noted. The highest praise came from a seasoned traveler who remarked, "Having visited 42 countries and many wonderful places, my wife and I vowed never to return to the same location. Yet, Secret Bay and the stunning country of Dominica might just be the exception. It’s simply extraordinary and the finest property I’ve ever experienced in the Caribbean."

The Complete List

1. Secret Bay: Portsmouth, Dominica

Reader Rating: 98.53

2. Tensing Pen: Negril, Jamaica

Reader Rating: 98.07

3. Baoase Luxury Resort: Willemstad, Curaçao

Reader Rating: 97.79

4. Jade Mountain: Soufrière, St. Lucia

WBA Hall of Fame inductee. Reader Rating: 97.75

5. Cala Hotel: Grenada

Reader Rating: 97.11

6. Jamaica Inn: Ocho Rios, Jamaica

WBA Hall of Fame inductee. Reader Rating: 95.38

7. The Loren at Pink Beach: Bermuda

Reader Rating: 95.19

8. Lovango Resort & Beach Club: St. John, U.S. Virgin Islands

Reader Rating: 95.15

9. Jumby Bay Island, Oetker Collection: St. John's, Antigua and Barbuda

Reader Rating: 94.96

10. Rockhouse: Negril, Jamaica

Reader Rating: 94.90

11. Seven Stars Resort & Spa: Turks and Caicos

Reader Rating: 94.79

12. Curtain Bluff: Antigua and Barbuda

Reader Rating: 94.15

13. Cap Maison: St. Lucia

Reader Rating: 93.83

14. Anse Chastanet Resort: Soufrière, St. Lucia

Reader Rating: 93.64

15. Windjammer Landing Villa Beach Resort: Castries, St. Lucia

Reader Rating: 96

16. Ambergris Cay: Turks and Caicos

Reader Rating: 93.18

17. The Ocean Club, a Four Seasons Resort: Paradise Island, Bahamas

Reader Rating: 93.14

18. Half Moon: Montego Bay, Jamaica

Reader Rating: 93.04

19. Malliouhana: Meads Bay, Anguilla

Reader Rating: 93.04

20. Frangipani Beach Resort: Meads Bay, Anguilla

Reader Rating: 93.00

21. Rosewood Little Dix Bay: Virgin Gorda, British Virgin Islands

Reader Rating: 92.86

22. Sugar Beach, a Viceroy Resort: Soufrière, St. Lucia

Reader Rating: 92.69

23. Aurora Anguilla Resort & Golf Club: Anguilla

Reader Rating: 92.65

24. The Ritz-Carlton, Grand Cayman: Grand Cayman, Cayman Islands

Reader Rating: 92.53

25. Couples Sans Souci: Ocho Rios, Jamaica

Reader Rating: 92.50