What is Superman Ice Cream?

If you're from Michigan, you should know the answer to this: What exactly is Superman ice cream?

Though, if you're from Michigan (or perhaps Wisconsin or any other Midwest state), you might still be unsure about the answer to that question.

Superman ice cream, much like its namesake superhero, has an air of mystery about it. But don't worry, we'll clear up some of the confusion so your next scoop can be less of a riddle.

What is Superman Ice Cream?

Superman ice cream is made up of three vibrant flavors, each colored in the bold hues of blue, red, and yellow—just like Superman's iconic outfit. Think of it as a colorful twist on the classic Neapolitan, with each shade representing a distinct flavor.

The origins of Superman ice cream can be traced back to Michigan during the Prohibition Era (the 1920s). Legend has it that Detroit's Stroh's Brewery created the first batch of this vibrant treat, mixing together lemon, Redpop (Faygo's strawberry soda), and blue moon ice creams.

Blue moon is a peculiar flavor of ice cream that's just as mysterious as it is delicious. The bright blue scoop has a taste that baffles even the most seasoned ice cream lovers. Some say it’s a citrusy vanilla blend, while others claim it has fruity notes of raspberry and lemon.

Though it shares its name with a famous comic book hero, Superman ice cream actually predates the DC character. The bold, colorful ice cream was likely given the name later on, thanks to its eye-catching appearance. You'll also find the same red, blue, and yellow combo under names like Super Rainbow, Super Coop, and Scooperman.

What Flavor Is Superman Ice Cream?

The precise mix of flavors in Superman ice cream is a closely guarded secret by the makers who create this iconic treat. However, some have let a few details slip, giving their fans a glimpse behind the curtain.

Superman ice cream's flavors may include the following:

Some ice cream makers simply mix three different shades of vanilla to create Superman ice cream. While it gives your tongue a blue tint, it’s not quite as flavorful as the real deal. To be truly authentic, each color should represent a distinct flavor, though the specific combinations vary depending on the manufacturer (and they may not be eager to share their secret recipe).

Where to Find Superman Ice Cream

Superman ice cream is widely available in the Midwest, especially in Michigan, Ohio, and Wisconsin. You can also find the colorful treat in select grocery stores and specialty ice cream parlors in other parts of the country.

If you're in the Midwest, finding Superman ice cream is a breeze—just head to your local ice cream parlor, grocery store, or sweet shop.

Outside the Midwest, your best bet is to check those same places, though you might need to place a special order or look for stores that carry Midwestern ice cream brands.

• Michigan-based Hudsonville ice cream sells their Super Scoop across the country. Their product locator can help you find a retailer near you.
• Wisconsin's Cedar Crest Ice Cream offers bundles of pints for shipping nationwide, and they sell the flavor as Super Madness.
• Grocery store Meijer's sells their own Scooperman pints.