Dinogo Readers' Top 5 Island Picks in Mexico, Central, and South America for 2024

Regardless of the type of island escape you've imagined, it's likely a reality waiting to be explored along the coasts of Central America, South America, and Mexico. These waters are dotted with countless picturesque beach islands, each offering a unique experience. Whether you're seeking thrilling underwater diving and wildlife encounters or serene coconut palm groves, this region can fulfill your tropical island dreams. Find out which islands in Mexico, Central America, and South America captivated Dinogo readers in 2024.

Understanding the Voting Process

Each year, for our World's Best Awards survey, T+L invites readers to share their travel experiences worldwide — providing insights on the finest hotels, resorts, cities, islands, cruise lines, spas, airlines, and more. In 2024, over 186,000 T+L readers participated in the survey, casting more than 700,000 votes across 8,700+ properties (including hotels, cities, cruise lines, etc.).

Islands were rated based on the following criteria:

Natural attractions/beaches
Activities/sights
Dining options/food
People/friendliness
Value for money

Respondents rated each attribute as excellent, above average, average, below average, or poor. The final scores represent the average of these ratings.

What Readers Appreciated

Along the Belize Barrier Reef, renowned for the iconic Great Blue Hole, both Caye Caulker (No. 2) and Ambergris Caye (No. 3) continue to be popular choices this year. Although both islands feature stunning white sand beaches and vibrant tropical scenery, they offer distinct experiences. Caye Caulker is celebrated for its backpacker-friendly, relaxed atmosphere. One reader referred to it as "the little sister to Ambergris Caye," commending its small-town vibe and diverse dining scene, while Ambergris Caye leans more towards luxury with its upscale hotels and resorts.

Located just off the coast of Cancun's Hotel Zone, Isla Mujeres (No. 4) boasts a vastly different ambiance compared to the lively, resort-dominated mainland. Here, life flows at a more leisurely pace, and its main beach, Playa Norte, is among the most picturesque in Mexico. One reader mentioned visiting 20 times over 30 years, while another expressed a desire to relocate there if given the chance.

In Honduras, one reader referred to Roatán Island (No. 5) as a hidden gem, while many others applauded its stunningly unspoiled beaches, calm waters ideal for snorkeling, and relatively low tourist traffic.

The Galápagos Islands in Ecuador reclaimed the No. 1 position this year, maintaining its title for the 24th year in a row. This remarkable destination, known for adventure, frequently tops travelers' bucket lists due to its ecological richness and untouched environment, which is why readers continuously praise it.

The Champion

Galápagos Islands: Ecuador

Two Galapagos Tortoises enjoying a conversation while lounging

paulacobleigh/Getty Images

Readers unanimously agree: the Galápagos Islands in Ecuador are essential for every nature enthusiast, boasting 9,000 unique species within its ecosystems and surrounding waters. This remarkable archipelago gained fame in the 19th century, thanks to Charles Darwin's exploration of its incredible wildlife diversity. Little has changed since then, adding to the enchantment and intrigue of South America's most renowned island chain. One reader expressed, "There’s nowhere else on Earth like these islands,” while another shared that their "soul was soothed" by the sights and felt "privileged to witness the numerous natural wonders" found here.