Heading to a cruise line's private island? Avoid these 11 common mistakes

Cruise line private islands offer stunning tropical getaways with pristine beaches, comfy lounge chairs, refreshing cocktails served to you, and exciting activities like water sports and zip-lining. Don’t spoil the fun by making a vacation misstep that could turn your dream day into a regretful one.

These 11 typical mistakes catch both beginners and seasoned cruisers off guard when visiting famous private islands in the Caribbean and Bahamas. Be prepared to enjoy your island getaway without any travel headaches.

Staying on the ship

Some cruisers new to the experience might not consider themselves "beach enthusiasts" and think there's no reason to disembark at a private island. However, island days offer far more than just beach lounging—you’re missing out if you stay on the ship.

Water-based excursions are plentiful, whether you want to paddle through the waters on a kayak, glide in a glass-bottom boat, or zip around on a personal watercraft. You can swim with stingrays, try fishing, or even embark on tours to nearby islands.

For instance, on Carnival Corporation’s Half Moon Cay, horseback riding along the shoreline is a favorite activity. You can tour the island’s farm to learn about local flora and agriculture. Nature walks lead to historic limestone fishing hut ruins from the 18th century and offer views of the island’s nesting seabirds.

At Royal Caribbean’s Perfect Day at CocoCay, you'll find thrilling attractions, including North America's tallest waterslide and the Caribbean's largest freshwater pool, along with zip lines and even balloon rides.

All tours require advance reservations.

Walking to the beach

Your cruise line's private island may be larger than expected. Getting from the disembarkation point to the beach could involve a lengthy walk along boardwalks or sandy paths. Don’t make the mistake of hauling all your gear to the far end of the beach when some cruise lines offer open-air trams to take you directly to your destination.

If you’re keen on stretching your legs, check the island map for recommended hiking trails, or rent a bike to explore on two wheels. (Be sure to book your bike in advance, as rentals may require a reservation.)

Snagging the first beach chair you spot

It’s tempting to claim the first available beach chair you find, but if you choose one near the pier, you'll end up in the busiest, loudest part of the island. Keep in mind that multiple ships may dock at the island at once, so the area near the pier fills up quickly. Venture farther away from the ship (and the noisy bars), and you'll discover a quieter, more serene spot.

Some islands offer multiple beaches, so don’t settle for the first one you come across. For example, Disney Cruise Line's Castaway Cay features designated beaches for families and teens, while Serenity Bay, a beautiful mile-long stretch on the island's northern side, is exclusively for adults.

Tip: If you’re planning to snorkel from the beach, try to find a quieter spot away from the crowds for a better, more peaceful experience with marine life.

Postponing your cabana or villa booking

Cruise lines offer private open-air beach (or pool) cabanas for hundreds of dollars per day and luxurious air-conditioned beach villas that can cost over $1,000. These exclusive spots provide VIP treatment and extra perks during your island visit. Despite the hefty price, they’re in high demand and often sell out quickly.

Since cabanas book up fast, the best strategy is to reserve them as soon as you’re able to book excursions for your cruise. Suite guests may get priority, so if you wait too long, your chance of lounging on a peaceful beach or enjoying butler-served meals may slip away.

Waiting to rent water sports gear

On your cruise line's private island, you'll find small kiosks with a limited selection of floating beach mats, snorkels, fins, kayaks, stand-up paddleboards, and other water activities. To make sure you get the equipment you want, it's best to reserve it before your trip or while still on board the ship. You don’t want to be the parent who has to break the bad news that the floats are all gone.

Assuming shade is free

Cruise lines offer free lounge chairs on their private islands, but they don’t always include free shade. While some islands provide beach umbrellas, they may come with an extra charge. Clamshell covers for chairs almost always cost extra, so it’s a good idea to reserve one ahead of time as they tend to sell out quickly.

A free alternative is to drag your beach chair into the shade of nearby palm trees, where you may also find hammocks. However, these shady spots could already be taken by clamshell rentals or may require a walk down the beach to access. If you're not picky, you can always retreat to shaded areas near bars or buffets — though these spots might not offer the best scenery for relaxing.

Skipping the barbecue

Some people disembark in the morning, get bored by noon, and head back to the ship for lunch. They miss out on the fun of enjoying a beachside picnic, either at the provided tables or right from their lounge chairs. (Sure, sand may get involved, but it’s all part of the experience.)

If you’ve never tried the barbecue on a private island, skipping this outdoor dining experience is a mistake. Depending on the cruise line, you'll find grilled burgers, hot dogs, jerk chicken, ribs, steaks, corn on the cob, plus an array of salads, desserts, and fresh fruit — all served buffet-style under a spacious pavilion.

Also, don’t assume that the lunch offerings on every private island are the same. For instance, while both Carnival Cruise Line and Holland America visit Half Moon Cay, each cruise line offers a different beach barbecue menu. Both are worth sampling.

Overlooking other lunch options

While the island barbecue is a classic part of the private island experience, some destinations offer additional lunch choices that are worth exploring. Be sure to check all available dining options before diving in, as you could miss out on a special meal.

For example, Holland America has a venue serving grilled lobster and conch stew for an extra charge. Norwegian cruises delight food lovers with complimentary food trucks offering tacos, ceviche, and pulled pork sandwiches. At MSC Cruises' Ocean Cay, you can purchase a lobster roll and enjoy ice cream served in a fish-shaped cone (also for an extra fee).

In addition to its two free barbecue locations, Royal Caribbean’s Perfect Day at CocoCay features three Snack Shack outlets, an à la carte menu at Captain Jack's bar, and exclusive dining options for cruisers who pay for access to the Coco Beach Club and Hideaway Beach.

Entering private staff zones

To keep the beaches and other amenities in top shape, your cruise line employs staff, some of whom live on the island. Other workers are often locals who come in for the day. Their village area, which includes a kitchen, power generator, water and sewage facilities, recreation hall, and other essentials, is designated as private. Treat this space as you would someone’s home and avoid entering.

Forgetting to bring your own snorkels and beach gear

Avoid spending a fortune on rentals when you can easily bring your own snorkel gear to the beach. A family of four could save $120 or more in rental fees by bringing their own equipment. Plus, you can ensure a perfect fit for your masks and avoid the uncertainty of shared gear.

If there’s room in your luggage, consider packing beach toys for the kids—such as buckets, shovels, and beach balls—so they don’t end up bored or begging you to buy overpriced toys from the island shops. Inflatable balls and floats are easy to pack and will keep the little ones entertained while you unwind.

Forgetting essential beach items

If you quickly throw a few items into your beach bag just before heading off the ship, you’re likely to leave something behind. Prepare your beach essentials the night before so you’re not stuck paying overpriced fees at the island's straw market.

Don’t forget sunscreen, hats, and sunglasses. You may also want a cover-up for the barbecue lunch and either water shoes or closed-toe shoes for certain activities. Some cruise lines require you to bring your own pool towel from the ship—don’t assume towels will be waiting for you on the island.

It’s also a good idea to carry a few dollars for souvenirs at the straw market or to tip the island staff, especially if you’ve rented a cabana with a personal attendant.